Combat Shotguns

My wife recently got into a few Facebook debates about gun control. One guy mentioned ‘combat shotguns’ and believes that they should be banned/restricted/whatever. Let’s examine that idea. At least for this argument, let’s agree that combat shotguns are bad and we want to restrict them.

So, what is a combat shotgun? How are they different from hunting and competition shotguns?

If I designed a shotgun for combat, I would want several things:

  1. durable so that it doesn’t break (stop working)
  2. reliable so that it doesn’t jam (stop working)
  3. light weight enough to carry all day
  4. heavy weight enough that it doesn’t kick too much
  5. useful at short range

Those first 4 items are equally useful for hunters and target competitors.

How do we make a shotgun ‘useful at short range’? Well, it probably has a short barrel so that it can be swung and pointed inside of small rooms.

Ok, so we’ve decided that shotguns with short barrels should be restricted. How short is too short? How long should be unrestricted? How about 18 inches?

We already have that law. Shotguns with barrels less than 18″ are heavily restricted (see ‘National Firearms Act’ 1934). That’s why shotguns with 18.5″ and 20″ barrels are often marketed as ‘home defense’ or ‘combat’ shotguns. If the limit had be set at 14″, then we’d have gun stores filled with 14″ shotgun barrels. If the limit had been set at 22″ then we’d have gun stores filled with 22″ shotgun barrels.

And of course, all of this ignores the simple fact that criminals can use a hacksaw to chop a long barrel into a short barrel. In the end, the restrictions are quite useless. Laws can only ever restrict the law-abiding.

Edited for typos 7/23 8:40pm

Advertisements

About jurmond

'Jurmond' was the name of my first character in a homebrew D&D campaign. He was a gunslinger and tinker, creating and carrying strange weapons that belched fire and smoke. That was well over a decade ago but I still think of him whenever fiction and firearms collide, so it seems the perfect pen name for this project.
This entry was posted in firearms, politics. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Combat Shotguns

  1. jurmond says:

    Oh, and it should be noted that a shorter barrel means less muzzle velocity (less power) and shorter range. There’s a myth that a shotgun’s wide spread is good. No, wide spread decreases the useful range of a shotgun. The wider the pellets spread out, the fewer pellets that hit the target. If half the pellets miss the target, then the pellets can only do half as much damage.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s